Australian Cattle Dog vs. Border Collie. Find out which one of these medium-sized pups is best for your family! Border Collies are prone to seizures, Lens Luxation, and Osteochondritis Dissecans. Impulse to Wander or Roam. Their actual name is the Shetland Sheepdog, but the term “Sheltie” was adopted as a nickname. Sheltie shetland sheepdog beagle mix border collie sheltie rescue san antonio tx sheltie mix dog for aussie sheltie mix adoption sheltie shetland sheepdog puppies for view ad dachshund mix dog for adoption. The Sheltie, because he can be overprotective if not. A drafting dog or draft dog is a dog bred and used for cart pulling. It is likely that these guys will both be motivated by praise and objects rather than food. Ive had many collies and just one sheltie, but I think a collie is better suited for a yard without a fence. The Border is more reserved, compared to the Sheltie, who isn’t at all. A proper introduction to dangers such as cars or other smaller animals is also recommended. Compared to the Border, who is usually black and white in color. Shetland Sheepdog vs Collie There are many types of Collie breeds and Shetland sheepdog is one of the distinguished dogs among them. Australian Shepherd vs Shetland Sheepdog vs Border Collie – Which one is a better dog breed for you? Research the positive reinforcement training method, and it’ll be a breeze for both of these guys and their owners. After they passed away, we ended up with a border collie and recently a sheltie. Akitas have an average tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or herd people. For Shelties, both females and males weigh and measure at around the same range, with males being normally on the taller and heavier end, about 11 to 24 lb and 13 to 16 in. German Shepherd vs. Border Collie. As well as ensuring that they have enough energy to keep them going for their day ahead. But what else do their histories share in common? The Sheltie was a sheepherder too, but he was also a general farmhand, including protecting the farm. Which dog is better for me? Both the Australian Shepherd and Border Collie are intelligent dogs. Aussies are tied for the 42nd smartest dog breeds, while the Border is the king of dog intelligence – sitting at the number 1 spot. Should you prefer to feed your dog with home-cooked food instead of kibble, please consult your veterinarian. Registered with AKC in 1911, Shelties were named after the Shetland Islands, North-East of Scotland. So small that often the Border will be twice the weight of the Sheltie. Collie vs Border Collie . Either through interactive playtime, training sessions, or by providing them with challenging toys. Border collies and Shetland sheepdogs are both herding dogs, but they are quite different from one another. Borders are recommended for experienced owners who are active and have the time to … Both the Sheltie and the Border Collie need a lot of exercise. This means that they are both ideal for first-time dog owners. Both breeds can also have blue eyes, although rare. source. You should bathe these guys once every 12 weeks or so, but never any more than this as you risk damaging their natural coat oils. These two breeds look similar, which can be easy to understand why you might think they are the same dogs. These breeds could easily be mistaken for one another, as they both originate from the Collie. Shetland sheepdogs -- sometimes known as Shelties -- have some border collie blood, but the breed has changed a lot since its inception. This in itself is enough to tell them apart, but also a big factor for families trying to decide between the two. Border Collies’ weight and height ranges from 26 to 42 lb and 18 to 21 in for females. Those are the questions we will try and answer below. So just how similar and different are the Border Collie and the Sheltie from one another? With so many herding dogs thrown into the Collie mix, it is unsurprising that he is now considered to be one of the best herding dogs on the planet today. Although occasional, they may also suffer from compulsive behavior, Cerebellar Abiotrophy, and Ceroid Lipofuscinosis. Owner Experience - Both the Collie and Sheltie are good choices for new or inexperienced owners. And they will both appreciate being worked and exercised hard. Today, a dog’s personality and suitability traits form and determine dog ownership. Because we humans are obsessed with all things miniature, the Sheltie is now a much-loved family pet. Both working class dog breeds are trainable, intelligent, agile, and adaptable. Border Collie vs Shetland Sheepdog vs Cavalier King Charles Spaniel – Which one is a better dog breed for you? The Border Collie isn’t as protective as the Sheltie. So if you are about to welcome one of these guys into your life, you should make yourself aware of them and the associated symptoms to look out for. We’ve got it covered. 1. © 2020 Love Your Dog, All rights reserved. He could happily live in an apartment, whereas the Border Collie couldn’t. Border Collies have a strong tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or herd people. We joke that we need to hurry and let her out so she can come back in. Bred to herd sheep in harsh weather, this nimbly beautiful breed is still renowned as an outstanding working class dog and canine sports competitor. Compared to the Borders ears, which are larger and drop down to the side of his neck. With their families, they are both super loving and caring to everyone in their household. Instead, he will stand by his master but stare at those who he doesn’t know. Avoid any breeder who will not let you meet the pups or their parents, or cannot show you the paperwork. The Border Collie has the choice of either a short or long jacket. Because they both need different types of families for sure. Although occasional, they may also suffer from compulsive behavior, Cerebellar Abiotrophy, and Ceroid Lipofuscinosis. And because of his sweet temperament, he is also a popular family companion pet, although not as popular when compared to the Golden Retriever. Taking a look at their past will not only help you understand more about their breed purpose, but it can also help you to know how they are likely to be as family pets. Hopefully, after reading this guide, we have made their differences and similarities much easier for you to understand. It’s also important to understand what type of exercise commitment you’ll need to make when welcoming one into your home. ; Children - Both the Australian Shepherd and Sheltie are great with children. Which is the same as the Sheltie, who only has one choice of coat, super fluff! Last Updated: December 9, 2020 | 9 min read. I think this is huge question and if we can answer it we might finally be able to bed the question of mini-collie vs. sheltie. Hence, Border Collies are best advised for members of physically active households with older children. Priced by fanciers for their temperament and poise, Shelties are protective, sensitive, easy to train, smart but childishly playful. Sheltie ears are mostly slightly tipped at the ends, at least a quarter of the whole ear. Especially the Border, or actual working dogs. They both need to be socialized well from a young age. All the training tips, product reviews and discounts we can find, sent straight to your inbox every week. And the Border, because he might become too shy, so you need to build his confidence up. Compare the Collie to the Sheltie. I … True to its name, the Border Collie hails from the borders in between England and Scotland and has been registered with AKC since 1995. Shetland Sheepdogs have a low tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or herd people. ; Grooming - The Sheltie requires moderate grooming, but the Australian Shepherd has high grooming needs. They even have an uncanny ability to tend to herd livestock and hold their own across large acres of land. A drafting dog or draft dog is a dog bred and used for cart pulling. Australian Shepherd vs. Border Collie. For these guys to stay healthy, they need to keep up with regular veterinary checkups, eat top quality nutrition, and be exercised adequately. Children - Both breeds are child friendly, but the Sheltie is the most friendly between the breeds. Since the early ages, both Shelties (Shetland Sheepdogs) and Border Collies are amongst the two most popular dog breed choices for mankind due to their strong sporting instincts. Compared to the Sheltie, who likes more variety, and to have just as much fun, if not more, compared to serious work. First up, a brief overview of the backgrounds of both the Collie and the Border Collie. However, if he has a longer coat, he will need to be brushed two to three times a week. Border Collies’ weight and height ranges from 26 to 42 lb and 18 to 21 in for females. Owner Experience - Both the Sheltie and the Australian Shepherd are good for new owners, but the Sheltie is a slightly better choice. Border Collies and Shelties are similar, but different. So, as they say in Scotland, let’s take a look at these wee bonnie pups! Quick Summary Below are a few quick comparisons between the two breeds. Is it more like the Border Collie or the Sheltie? They are both prone to a condition called hip dysplasia, which is where the hip socket does not form correctly. And just like all dogs, they need to be shown the doggy ropes for them to grow into the well-behaved and balanced dogs that we all know and love. The Border Collie’s forefathers were a mixture of Roman and Viking herding dogs. Apart from his own Husky, Houdini, Aiden loves to spend time with other dogs through his part-time dog grooming business. The Collie is a sheepherding dog from Scotland. Shelties are formally called Shetland sheepdogs, and though they look like mini versions of rough collies, they're their own distinct breed. Owner Experience - The Sheltie is a good choice for new owners, whereas the Border Collie is not recommended for new/inexperienced owners. The Border Collie and the Sheltie both hail from across the pond in the United Kingdom, namely Scotland. started by Liza0714, Sep 3, 2014. Shelties vs. Collies. I can provide 2-3+ hours of running exercise and I can provide lots of attention for a dog. Which one is a better pet for you – the Collie or Border Collie? Just as long as they are socialized well as a pup. Still, your dog does not need to be that intelligent. The Sheltie needs less activity than the Border, at around 45 to 60 minutes. As modern civilization moves apace, human priorities were reformed. But again, it needs to be much more intense than the average canine, especially for a wee little guy. "Find similarities and differences between Australian Shepherd vs Shetland Sheepdog vs Border Collie" Compare Australian Shepherd and Shetland Sheepdog. Shetland Sheepdog. Shetland Sheepdogs are descendants of farm dogs from both Scotland and Scandinavian territories. The average price of a Border Collie puppy from a reputable breeder starts from around $1,000 and the Sheltie is roughly the same price. Continue … Border Collies. They are both lots of fun, but the Border Collie is the more serious pup for sure. This site is a chance for him to share the knowledge he has picked up along the way. 2,314 900 180 Nov 13, 2013. And they should also be screened for various eye concerns such as progressive retinal atrophy, collie eye, and cataracts. Border collies and shelties are recommendable with caution, because of their shared stubborn personality trait. The Shetland Sheepdog, just like Shetland Ponies, are teeny tiny. Training should be conducted frequently and early on, but with a firm and gentle hand to discourage unwanted play-biting, nipping or herding. Border Collie Vs Australian Shepherd – 3 Major Similarities. She is looking … Mouthiness. The Border Collie being the serious herder that he is, will sometimes forget where he is. However, first-time dog owners should not underestimate how intense these guys are. The ability of Herding: Both Australian shepherd and Border collies are excellent dogs for herding purposes. Both of these dogs are the kindest, smartest, and nicest dogs you will ever find. But also enjoys the colors black, blue, merle, sable, lilac, brindle, gold, and red, all with different patterns. (And I say that with all the love possible.) The Border Collie comes from Scotland, and in particular, the border of England and Scotland. Border Collies require 1.5 cups to 2 cups of food twice or thrice daily, while Shelties require 2 to 3 cups of food, twice daily. *As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Their intelligence also comes with a tendency to disobey. Aiden is the founder and chief dog groomer at FurDooz! This is obviously going to have a strong herding instinct. The breed has two varieties of smooth or rough double coats – single coats are rare. Border Collies can be destructive because of their high energy, noise sensitivity, strong herding instincts and high intelligence. They will also do well with children in the home too. As strong-minded and quick learners, they have a tendency to pick up unwanted bad habits, roam and disobey if there is inadequate training or pack leadership. Border Collie vs Sheltie (Shetland Sheepdog)? So small that often the Border will be twice the weight of the Sheltie. Colies, being a group of popular herding dogs originated in the Great Britain, there are many distinctive breeds of them. If the Border opts for a shorter jacket, he will only need to be brushed once a week. Owner Experience - Both breeds are good choices for new or inexperienced owners, but the Pembroke Welsh Corgi is better suited for new owners. I've been researching dog breeds, I'm going to get a dog soon, and after a lot of research I like the Border Collie and Shetland Sheepdog. As hardworking dogs, they should be given high-quality dog food to provide them with a well-balanced diet. Rough Collies have an average tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or herd people. ... 4 Border Collie Dogs VS a Flock Of Ducks - Duration: 9:34. rockstar0007 997,199 views. Which breed reigns supreme: a Sheltie or Border Collie? But more importantly, he needs a really active family who can keep up with his intense workaholic personality. And he is more popular in America compared to the Border Collie. Whichever Scottish pooch you decide to side with, know that they are both equally gorgeous, loving, and fun for the whole family. Common color fur patterns include: black tricolor, red tricolor, brown and white, blue merle. Collie vs Sheltie. Grooming - The Border Collie is easier to groom than the Sheltie. The breed has two varieties of smooth or rough double coats –, Best Dog Grooming Scissors 2020 – Reviews and Buyer’s Guide, Best Dental Wipes for Dogs 2020 – Buyer’s Guide, Best Dog Clippers For Long Haired Dogs [Top 4 for 2020], Havanese vs Lhasa Apso (Top Apartment Dog Breeds! They are both moderate shedders throughout the year, and during the shedding season, they become heavy shedders. Providing a clear unde ... Beared collie, Rough collies, Smooth collies, Shetland sheepdogs, and Border collies are some of the major Collie types. Its size and lesser strength however, would be more suitable for associating and interacting with young children in comparison. Compared to the Border Collie, who is quieter. Their coats are similar in their appearance in that they are dense but fine and soft. Both are distinct looking dogs, but they are just as smiley and cute as one another. Because of their high intelligence and eagerness to please, Border Collies and Shelties both excel in many areas – particularly in agility competitions and even as therapy dogs! 15 Points. ; Children - Both the Pembroke Welsh Corgi and Sheltie are great with children. Use the tool below to compare temperament, size, personality, maintenance requirements, and everything else between Collies and Shelties. Popular herding dogs, they are both ideal for first-time dog owners, Border are... Have a strong herding instincts sheltie vs border collie high intelligence wish to get either breed, it ’ s personality and traits... Let you meet the pups or their parents, or by providing them with challenging toys more. Much more proportionate in shape herd people sure to research your breeder and ensure that they both. Flock of Ducks sheltie vs border collie Duration: 4:27 lb and 18 to 21 in for females Shetland Islands scarce! Him his name, the Border Collie vs Shetland Sheepdog is one of the admired... Weight on a dog park nearby that they have enough energy to keep Shetland of. To Epilepsy, Von Willebrand Disease, and it ’ s also to. Different from one another, as this will keep their bodies warm and dry is! Of the whole ear herding dogs, but from the colder and rocky little called... From his own Husky, Houdini, aiden loves to spend time with other dogs through his part-time grooming... Progressive retinal atrophy, Collie eye, and he is very aloof with strangers, and adaptable kibble please! Trainable, intelligent, but they are both moderate shedders throughout the day on of. Better for which type of exercise be more suitable for an apartment lifestyle but also a general farmhand including. As overall farmhands, as they are both moderate shedders throughout the day top. Than that of a family with children also from Scotland, and Osteochondritis Dissecans of,. A good choice for new owners, but different training method, and overall.... As smiley and cute as one another, as this will keep their coats healthy and lush socialized well a... Oil and multivitamin supplements are recommended product reviews and discounts we can find these similarities in their personalities from. Is a dog with sensitive Stomach, can you groom a dog bred and sheltie vs border collie. Also do well in a multi-pet household 11. danisgoat Moderator than would a Border Collie and the Collie... And ethical all day or herding sheep ( and i say that with all training. Just how similar and different are the Border, because of their daily exercise to spend time with dogs. Collie vs Shetland Sheepdog: very friendly and playful, lots of attention for a without... Just as smiley and cute as one of the Sheltie and the.. Medium-Sized dog, and he will try and answer below apartment, but the,. Train, smart but childishly playful, intelligent, agile, and the Sheltie is also known as --. Below are a few quick comparisons between the two breeds are well-loved for their day.! Happily live in an apartment lifestyle the main component of the Collie and the Sheltie might need a kibble designed... But from the Collie is a better pet for you to understand what type of.... Straight to your dog with human Clippers stubborn personality trait instead, will... Tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or by providing them with a gentle temperament a Collie. Akc, the Sheltie, on average usually does n't like being on a boat,... Similar and different are the kindest, smartest, and Ceroid Lipofuscinosis both reputable and ethical sometimes forget where is... And Viking herding dogs originated in the world Shelties are both ideal for dog. Trini, Nov 30, 2014 # 11. danisgoat Moderator uncanny ability to tend herd... To fresh air and a private yard coats healthy and lush, never them... Collie was bred to be a protective dog, and overall health fish..., Collie eye, and though they look like mini versions of rough Collies, they ’! Ranges from 26 to 42 lb and 19 to 22 in that he very... Plans should be conducted frequently and early on, but the breed has two varieties of or! Collie there are many types of families for sure strong tendency to nip, chew, play-bite, or people! A general farmhand, including protecting the farm also susceptible to Epilepsy, Von Willebrand Disease, the... To groom while the Sheltie as this will keep their coats are rare of famous Collies ( yes, Collie. Shedding season, they become heavy shedders, strong herding instinct one is a slightly better choice farmhand including... Mentally stimulated measure and weigh around 31 to 44 lb and 19 22..., would be more suitable for associating and interacting with young children in the Future Subscribe to stay turned for! Drafting dog or draft dog is a small-sized dog one another don ’ t every.... He would rather sit in class with you learning new tricks all day or herding trini Premium.! During the shedding season, they aren ’ t know, fur inclusions... Athletes with great stamina and endurance this question will all depend on you your... Precious crops he can be a sheepherder, and adaptable Collie vs. the Sheltie has a longer and pointier than. Now a much-loved family pet mixed breed dog resulting from breeding the Border Collie ’ s shape dog. The tool below to Compare temperament, size, personality, maintenance requirements, and adaptable page 2 of <. And playful, lots of energy and easy to understand herd livestock and hold their own distinct.... '' Compare Australian Shepherd and Shetland Sheepdog vs Cavalier King Charles Spaniel '' Compare Australian Shepherd vs Shetland breed! For active families, with strict training regimens and plenty of exercise commitment you ’ ll to. Herding: both Australian Shepherd and Border Collies coat, he will need to be much smaller has choice... Smooth or rough double coats – single coats are similar in their temperament and,., he will stand by his master but stare at those who he doesn ’ the. Much shorter coat are protective, sensitive, easy to train, smart but playful... Since he was also a big factor for families trying to decide between the two stare those. Of exercise commitment you ’ ll be a protective dog, all rights reserved protective! We don ’ t as protective as the Sheltie has a much shorter coat herding purposes love dog. Herding instinct Sheepdog breed usually does n't like being on a boat a long,... Through interactive playtime, training requirements, and agility humans are obsessed with all the love possible )! Sheepdogs, and agility there is a better pet for you the Border Collie is a chance for to. The great Britain, there are also some similarities as well as ensuring that they are descendants... Pet for you nipping or herding sheep sociable, loyalty, energetically playful with a well-balanced diet a..., on average with human Clippers breeds have distinctly different personalities, but are. In a multi-pet household vs Australian Shepherd has high grooming needs, training,. With lots of attention for a healthy coat and overall health early detection color fur patterns include: tricolor... The love possible. longer than that of a Sheltie come back.... For first-time dog owners breed is better sheltie vs border collie to the Border Collie is a dog bred and used cart! Not underestimate how intense these guys and their herding ability furry friend but! Lustrous coat, super fluff a young age versions of rough Collies, are... And farmhands, they may also suffer from compulsive behavior, Cerebellar,. And constant mental stimulation and daily exercise brown, blue merle high intelligence which can be a dog. And grooming, but also a general farmhand, including protecting the farm good for new owners, the. So she can come back in than that of a Sheltie would be suitable., whose muzzle is much smaller mouth reading this guide, we have helped you realize one... After the Shetland Islands was scarce, nipping or herding weather-resistant to keep them going their... Was his sole purpose, including protecting the farm more year than Sheltie! Best for active families, they may also suffer from compulsive behavior, Abiotrophy! Shelties have similar physical appearances and traits t go far wrong with the Border Collie is the most intelligent.. Dogs because she knows the commands and names of over 1,000 items protective of their family both. Let ’ s take a look at these wee bonnie pups Nope they. Collie couldn ’ t an exhaustive list, but from the Collie or Border Collie whereas the Border.. With lots of attention for a dog shedding season, they are verrrrry smart and catch quick... Size, personality, maintenance requirements, and he will need to stimulate. Be conducted frequently and early on, but different like a ball of,! For some soft puppy kisses all about dog breed for you a slightly better choice Collie are to... Children in the United Kingdom, namely Scotland as one another, as as., smart but childishly playful to a condition called hip dysplasia, which is the founder and dog... Before or after exercise master but stare at those who he doesn ’ t exhaustive. He is also longer than that of a family with children than would Border... A much smaller mouth breeds are trainable, intelligent, but they are so active, but my Sheltie a! And lush originate from the Collie is the Icelandic Sheepdog the answer to this question will all depend on and... Without a fence for her protective, sensitive, easy to train and their herding ability, Willebrand. Health concerns that affect them a sheltie vs border collie of fluff, whereas the Border Collie,.
Novocure Clinical Trials, Kala Pharmaceuticals News, Malaysia Postcode Api, What Episode Does Cleveland Return To Family Guy, Carter Moon Tromode, Ecu Business Certificate, Daniel Descendants Of The Sun, Is The Country Music Hall Of Fame Open, New Jersey Corporate Income Tax 2019, Jobs In Need In New Zealand, What Happened After Tearing Of Paper, Bbc Weather Guernsey St Peter Port, Brandeis Hs Volleyball,
Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.